Monday, July 16, 2012

Zazen - Vanessa Veselka



    Ah, Zazen. A book so much closer to home than any other I’ve read so far, and in other ways, so distant and allegorized that I’m not sure how much of it I even understood.

    Zazen takes place in Portland, Oregon. It either takes place in a Portland a few years in the future, or it takes place in a distorted version of Portland as is. 

Basically, it’s raining bombs and everyone is doing yoga. Aside from the whole hell-on-earth thing, Portland is the same, but even more pretentious. Veganism reigns, “grassroots” is like a religion, and everyone complains. 

    Veselka writes in a snarky, biting way. Simultaneously, she gets to the truth of things, but can be opaque about others. I had a difficult time understanding the plot and I often felt like I didn’t get the joke.

    But here’s what really resonated with me: this new-age/hipster/radical-anarchist thing. It’s not the solution. It doesn’t alter the root systems of oppression; it doesn’t stop wars. It operates parallel to corruption, separate and distinct, but not against it.

    Especially because these new age movements are so fucking pretentious. Not always, of course, but far too often. Some of the most self-identified radical people I know are also the most judgmental, the most bitter, the most paralyzed. Again, I don’t want to generalize, but I’m sure that many activists can relate to what I’m talking about.

    Being judgmental about being vegan doesn’t change the system. Unfortunately, neither does blind acceptance and kindness. There’s a great passage of the novel, in which Della, the main character, calls in a bomb threat to her local yoga studio:

Yoga on the Hill, Devadatta speaking.
Get everyone out of the building –
Hold please –
[Della’s narration] Typing. Onine trying to befriend the entire country of Nepal.
-Sorry about that, how can I help you?
-This is a bomb threat.
I think you have the wrong number.
I don't.
Well, I can’t think of anyone who would want to blow us up.
I can.
Okay, well, I’ll let people know but there’s class going on right now and I think they’re all in Shavasana.
Perfect.


   Della is outraged by everyone – huge corporations like Walmart, strip joints that charge stage fees, as well as yoga studios that fancy themselves outside, or beyond, the order of things. Because as well-intentioned as these white, middle-upper class part-time yogis might be, they are not changing the world and are, in their way, contributing to class inequities and the global dilution of ancient wisdom.

 Where does that leave us? Well, it leaves Della with nothing and leads her to call in bomb threats just so everyone else can feel as paralyzed and powerless as she already feels. It’s hardly something I condone – I mean, who would? – but I get where she’s coming from. In this crazy world, it’s impossible not to feel despondent. The struggle is not to surrender to it.

Zazen will definitely be a book I return to, now that I understand its basic arc. And this time, I'll be sure to pay more careful attention to Veselka’s biting wit and to the narrative construction of her scathing social commentary.


-----


Next on the shelf: "Dancing with Cuba: A Memoir of the Revolution" - Alma Guillermoprieto


Krik, Krak? - Edwidge Danticat (Haiti)

Disclaimer: It’s been a while. I’ve been reading but not blogging. So, forgive me. I have a few updates, but they are brief and far more vague than I’m comfortable with. All of my books come from the libraries these days, so I have no primary sources to consult. So, the next two reviews will be shorter and a bit more self-absorbed than I care for!


     I’m not sure when I decided that I was going to be a humanitarian. I suppose it was way back when the word “humanitarian” didn’t strike me as pretentious. My idealism seemed rational; my grand ambitions seemed pure. In other words, it’s been a while.

      When people asked what I plan to do with my life, all I can tell them is my vision: I see myself working on grassroots humanitarian projects all over the world; 3-8 years in each place. I see myself and my daughter-to-be (it’ll be a girl, trust me) living simply, offering and sharing food with people. I see myself asking questions – to citizens, to people working at the NGO, to myself. I see myself offering perspective. I see myself making art, collecting art, writing. I see myself strong, confident, conscious.

     This vision is so deep that I can’t explain its origins. Nor can I explain its logistics – how I’ll pay for it, whether it’ll be safe. But what I truly suppress is the far more profound question, “Am I strong enough to do this work?”

      I knew when I selected Krik Krak that Haiti is one of the most violent, corrupt and polluted countries in the world. I had read Paul Farmer’s perspective on Haiti and wanted to hear about it from a local’s perspective. Still, by the end of the first page, I realized that Krik Krak was going to tear out my heart.

      Reading Krik Krak was like hurling yourself into a tsunami. In-between each story, a kind tide guides you back to shore, but you just can’t help yourself. You dive right back into the eye of the storm. This effect is aided by the short story format, for condensed tragedy is somehow even more tragic. You have just come to empathize with the characters and then they’re suddenly snatched from you.

     Danticat’s lens is versatile, elucidating the Haitian experience both on and off the island. The first story is comprised of unsent love letters between a young girl and her fugitive lover who escapes Haiti on a passenger ship. (Whenever a book starts out with people in love, you know it’s going to end badly. And indeed, it does.)  Danticat strings together a loose narrative arc, tying together the women in the stories through an implied familial connection. The gesture feels lovely and not at all contrived, as it binds the characters not only by the blood they share but also, and more profoundly, by the bloodshed they’ve witnessed.

    The later stories explore the Haitian-American immigrant experience. In the final story, “Caroline’s Wedding,” the mother objects to her daughter, Caroline’s marriage to a Jamaican man. With the hope of “curing” her fixation, Ma makes bone soup every day leading up to the marriage. Grace, Caroline’s sister, who just earned her US Citizenship must decide – if only for herself - with whom her allegiance stands: her history or her newly-earned future. Although neither Caroline nor her sister grew up amidst the same realities of their ancestors -- rampant witchcraft persecution, forced incest, a perpetual state of adrenaline  - they have inherited all of these through stories and there's no escaping them. 

    You could call it masochistic to read such a torturous book, to keep delving into story after story. But how can it be masochistic to read about people who’ve actually experienced torture? Whose families were slaughtered by sadists, who were forced to sleep with their mothers, brothers, fathers, before they were shot.

    In my last post, I wondered how much we could even understand stories from other cultures. I ask that question again with Krik? Krak! but even moreso. I suppose I take it as a given that writers write in order to connect. Orhan Pamuk writes The New Life and it becomes a global reference point for the current state of Turkey. He wants people to know what’s going on. But is that what Danticat wants? One could argue that she wants people to understand the brutality of life in Haiti - the unspeakable injustices; our excruciating privilege to be so ignorant of them. Was she reaching out to people like me, people with a sincere desire to contribute to the world’s betterment and a truckload of privilege with which to accomplish it?

    This is a reassuring thought: Danticat wants me to help prevent others from suffering. And yet, it feels disturbingly Western to interpret her work solely through this lens. Perhaps I am too cynical, but I have to wonder if Krik Krak was also meant to isolate. To make people ask, “What the fuck am I doing reading about these people? I have no place in this world, in their world.” To tell us to extinguish our idealism, to stop pretending we know what’s best, and to shut up and listen.